Lean supply chain the toyota motor company suggested the lean model in the 1970s, which focuses on eliminating waste, increasing speed and streamlining flow. The idea behind lean is that you use the least amount of time, effort, and resources by maintaining smooth and balanced flow in a supply chain. The paper examines the mediating effect of supply chain sc practices on the relationship between agile supply chain asc strategy and sc performance. Using the theoretical lenses of complementarity and the information processing view of the supply chain. Lean supply chain occurs when inventory moves so fast that firms basically holds zero inventory on hand. The purpose of this paper is to examine the role of strategic supplier partnership and postponement respectively, on the relation between lean and agile supply chain strategy and supply chain responsiveness. Lean and agile paradigms the table 8 indicates that for the illustrative are not mutually exclusive paradigms christopher problem the most signi.
Third category is a combination of lean and agile supply chain. Implementing the lean supply chain leancor supply chain group. The concepts of lean supply and 5s will be introduced followed by a discussion of how the 5s methodology may be used to develop and implement a supply strategy. The comparison of lean and agile, have certainly helped to make some intuitive sense about the concept of the agile supply chain. Introduction this cips knowledge summary paper does not attempt to. Difference between lean and agile compare the difference. But there comes a point at which lack of resources, be they materials, manpower or machinery, limits a supply chains ability to respond. Using lean and agile in combination is known as having a hybrid supply chain strategy. The evolution of the theory of lean supply chain management. But it would be more useful if some theoretical underpinning of the agile supply chain model can be provided. Supply chain management is rarely so simple, readers may be left wondering what are the options in the other two quadrants of your matrix, and what are the tradeoffs at the boundaries. Using the theoretical lenses of complementarity and the information processing view of the supply chain, we hypothesise. Zara the spanish fashion company provides a good example of this hybrid supply chain.
Periodicals too have only one article on lean supply chain. The lean supply chain is the traditional factory chain, which focuses on producing high volume at low cost. Lean supply chain and logistics management paul myerson. Also, the authors look at the relation between supply chain. Table 2 presents some of the key characteristics of the agile and lean manufacturing paradigms as supply chain strategies. This is met through the characteristics of logistics throughout the. Matt, your article is a sensible introduction to agile vs lean. This can be completes by agile manufacturing system. Purism is rarely the answer, and the worlds most intelligent supply chain professionals realize the value of nuance. When we talk about supply chain management strategies, there are two key approaches to understand. Continuous improvement is achieved by constantly evaluating the value added. And, like in a corporate merger, the integration of lean six sigma into an existing change culture requires training be done in the context of the organizations overall business and customer strategies. A lean supply chain is costconscious and efficient, but it wont be able to respond to new demands quickly.
Implementing supply chain strategy abstract supply chain strategy implementation is the process which merges together strategic management, supply chain management and supplier development. An agile supply chain is a system of product distribution concerned with doing things quickly, saving costs, being responsive to market. Implementing an agile supply chain allows organizations to quickly adjust their sourcing, logistics, and sales. Lean supply chain and logistics management paul myerson new york chicago san francisco lisbon london madrid mexico city milan new delhi san juan. Existent environment globalization of competition customer bargaining power increase demand for innovative product features more product varieties better performance and quality at a best in class and greater speed consumers expect fulfilment of demand almost instantly at a competitive price. One is lean supply chain strategy which is widely used in those markets where cost is the primary order winning criteria. The lean approach to supply chain management dummies. Then the journal european journal of purchasing and supply management and integrated manufacturing systems have two articles in each portfolio. Toyota motor corporation is currently one of the model companies worldwide in many aspects of conducting a successful business practice, including supply chain management. Originalityvalue this paper uses the findings of other researchers as a measure of the achievements of zara against academic theory. At the course of this process, three research questions have been formulated which stems for identifying those efficient metrics that affect logistics performance and the implementation of a lean agile supply chain design to improve on them. Supply operations often struggle to keep pace, as many arent sufficiently agile to capture fleeting upside opportunities or to mitigate fastmoving risks.
Additionally, companies with high volumes of low variability purchase orders. Systems, which combine the use of agile vendors with lean. Several case studies were included to support the presented considerations. The prior literature on strategy implementation and supply chain management is fragmented and provides only partial and often disconnected views. A leagile supply chain a lean supply chain focuses on promising the best customer value for a product ensuring the best quality.
Introduction to logistics and supply chain strategies. The lean theory also highlights that excess inventory tops the list of known wastes. Integrating the lean and agile manufacturing paradigms in the total supply chain j. Supply chain strategies for agility and responsiveness in a global marketplace table of contents 1. Disruption by design agile strategy for the new world 2016.
Nucharee supatn thammasat business school thammasat. Intransit merge network factories retailer product flow information flow intransit merge. The good news is you dont have to pick just one of these approaches to supply chain management. The goal is to add value for customers by reducing the cost of goods and lowering waste. At the course of this process, three research questions have been formulated which stems for identifying those efficient metrics that affect logistics performance and the implementation of a lean agile supply chain. Agile supply chain can you have one without the other. On the other hand, agile strategy ensures the minimum waiting time to deliver a product. Competing in volatile markets martin christopher cranfield school of management, uk turbulent and volatile markets are becoming the norm as lifecycles shorten and global economic and competitive forces create additional uncertainty.
Lean production and agile manufacturing, supply chain, lean supply, productivity. Apr 27, 2012 using lean to energize your supply chain the eight wastes lean opportunities and jit in supply chain and logistics lean tools and warehouse global lean supply chain and logistics lean opportunity assessment, value stream mapping, and kaizen event management bestinclass use of technology with lean metrics and measurement. Strategies to run a lean supply chain plant services. Agile vs lean supply chain management the junction llc. The supply chain permeates every facet of the enterprise, and if a lean approach to managing it is to succeed, the entire organization has to focus on removing waste and adding value. A hybrid supply chain strategy may be appropriate for a company attempting to become a mass. Lean and agile purchasing and supply management cips is expressing views on lean thinking and agility because it is an increasingly common activity and one which purchasing and supply management professionals should lead in their organisations. Responsive and agile based on product characteristics enterprise approach long lead times.
This methodology is important for organizations with high volumes of purchase orders since waste and costs can accumulate quickly. Large agile teams manage dependencies through multiple and iterative synchronization points, but they also work to remove them through better design process like lean s setbased and. Supply chain management in toyota motor corporation. This might suggest a correlation between lean and agile. Lean supply chain a lean supply chain is a set of organizations directly linked by upstream and downstream flows of products, services, finances and information that collaboratively work to reduce cost and waste by efficiently and effectively pulling what is needed to meet the needs of the individual customer 2. Third category is a combination of lean and agile supply chain which combines the. Combine several years of flat economic growth with a proliferation of online. Supply chain strategies can be divided roughly in three different categories. Professor alan harrison of cranfield university proposed a framework harrison, 1999 for agile supply chain. Table 2 is based upon literature regarding lean manufacturing, agile manufacturing and supply chain management and on industrial case studies. Lean vs agile supply chain is really the difference in emphasis.
Project supply chain management seeks value enhancement in projects through logistics focus on demand and supply alignment. Whereas agile supply chain methodology is all about being flexible. Second strategy is agile supply chain which is used in volatile markets where the order winner is availability. It further examines the moderating effect of information systems is capability for agility on this mediated relationship. In todays competitive markets, there is an increasing pressure on companies to make products more. Section 1 introduction and concepts logistics is not a new. Authors accepted manuscript the development of a lean, agile and leagile supply network taxonomy based on differing types of flexibility laura purvis, jonathan gosling, mohamed m. This has led to the emergence of the agile paradigm typified by quick response and similar initiatives. Lean management may be viewed as a precondition for agile management. Infographic can you run an efficient manufacturing and supply chain organisation without any lean or continuous improvement tools. Instead a supply chain may need to be lean for part of the time and agile. Instead a supply chain may need to be lean for part of the time and agile for the rest.
Jan 11, 2010 large agile teams manage dependencies through multiple and iterative synchronization points, but they also work to remove them through better design process like lean s setbased and concurrent. To shed light on the enablers and enemies of agility, we examined the supplychain performance of companies in five industries, as well as a range of practices that influence it. It is used as the basis of where to apply lean or agile strategy in a supply chain. Theorizing and moderated mediation analysis enables supply chain management scholars and practitioners to extend the boundaries of our present knowledge by examining how, when, and why lean, agile. Agile vs lean learn the top 9 differences and comparisons. While these strategies are often viewed as opposites, this research. This means that the use of efficient and structured lean resources can improve market orientation and positioning agile. Lean supply chain lsc can be defined as a set of organisations directly linked by upstream and downstream flows of products, services, finances and information that collaboratively work to reduce costs and waste vitasek et al. Lean and agile purchasing and supply management cips is expressing views on lean thinking and agility because it is an increasingly common activity and one which purchasing and supply management. Both agile vs lean are popular choices in the market. The gaps identified and challenges made will serve as a foundation upon which future researchers can build. Agile supply chain management focuses on the changing environment of business while lean supply chain is focused on quality control.
Lean supply chain is a huge topic, but understanding it and developing a strategy to eliminate as much waste as possible from your supply chain can pay big dividends in both value to the customer, as well as enhancing your companys profit and growth. A framework supporting the design of a leanagile supply. Supply chain management is a lean enterprise core competency. Towards achieving and maintaining excellence in supply chain. To improve a companys competitiveness and overall profitability, modern day businesses have embarked on new supply chain concepts of lean and agile supply chain.
A lean supply chain is established on the principle of eliminating waste any. Can you grow your company and be more responsive without using any agile supply chain. Originalityvalue to the authors knowledge, this is the. Deciding whether to adopt a lean or agile supply chain strategy can often be as simple as determining a products appeal, via basic market research, and establishing a supply chain. Written by robert martichenko, ceo of leancor supply chain group.
Keywords supply chain management, agile supply chain. Lean and agile supply chain strategies and supply chain. Does your company have a lean supply chain strategy, or are you looking to implement one in. The term lean supply implies that the supply chain is appropriate for lean production. The basic criteria for the evaluation of supply chains are leanness, ability to react and flexibility ciesielski 2001, pfhol 1999. Lean supply chain management is about reducing costs and lowering waste as much as possible. The comparison between lean and agile paradigm within the manufacturing environment has been discussed in various aspects. Agile supply chain is not the option available in market but a necessity for the success of the company. The merits of lean and agile supply chain strategies have been much debated among practitioners and academics. Lean supply chain management principles and practices. Just like in any major integration or merger of companies, training of resources must occur around new policies, products and procedures. Lean supply chain management principles derive from basic lean principles focus on the supplier network value stream eliminate waste synchronize flow minimize both transaction and production.
Lean is an approach to supply chain management that originated with toyota, which is why you may hear it referred to as the toyota production system tps. Modeling the metrics of lean, agile and leagile supply chain. Competing in volatile markets martin christopher cranfield school of management, uk. Jun 24, 2012 improvement in supply chain management can reduce costs for a company and increase the efficiency and requires a strategic approach to be implemented towards it. Lean in supply chain planning 5 lean principles in supply chain planning a lean supply chain planning process is one where improved performance is achieved by focusing on the customer, and creating a system that ensures value flows at the pull of the customer. Agile supply chain strategy and supply chain performance. In this paper, a brief overview of agile manufacturing system have been provided. Supply chain strategies for agility and responsiveness in. Many manufacturers and distributors in this country are familiar with the value of lean principles and operating a lean business. Understanding supply chain management strategies and finding one that works for your business. Supply chain management is rarely so simple, readers may be left wondering what are the options in the other two quadrants of your matrix, and.
Lean supply chain management principles derive from basic lean principles focus on the supplier network value stream eliminate waste synchronize flow minimize both transaction and production costs establish collaborative relationships while balancing cooperation and competition ensure visibility and transparency. Apr 21, 2014 the lean supply chain methodology is great for company products purchased in high volume but low variability. Agile supply chain connection to business strategy lean supply chain should be applied upstream the codp, while an agile supply chain would be more suitable for downstream operations the distinction between lean and agile has been tested empirically concerning drivers and performance outcomes. Periodic supply chain management stands out with 4 publications in literature that focus on portfolio theory building on lean supply chain. On the other hand, an agile supply chain is highly adaptable, but it can become hard to control and predict. Mar 21, 2012 excess stock in the supply chain, and the practice of increasing batch size to create efficiencies, are directly in conflict with responsiveness. Hence, many researchers have advocated that a lean focused supply chain. Agile software development model is like building a new thing which is for the first time and that too only for one time whereas lean.
663 213 101 1249 1189 136 21 180 809 504 533 724 1209 175 8 716 486 233 723 1103 526 1266 1368 935 351 321 439 468 1218 1407 1339 1338 1422 207 200 872 205 913 1199 1320 1396 1082 427 359 1111 1414